论文标题

探索表面特征与解释YouTube解释视频的质量之间的关系

Exploring the relationship between surface features and explaining quality of YouTube explanatory videos

论文作者

Bitzenbauer, Philipp, Höfler, Sebastian, Veith, Joaquin M., Winkler, Bianca, Zenger, Tim, Kulgemeyer, Christoph

论文摘要

近年来,关于解释性视频的物理教育研究经历了增强。由于在线可用的大量解释视频,例如在YouTube上,对于学习者,老师和讲师来说,找到高解释质量的视频是一项艰巨的任务。关于古典力学主题的解释性视频的解释质量的事先研究发现,YouTube提供的表面特征(例如,视图或喜欢的数量)似乎不是视频解释质量的适当指标。取而代之的是,发现与内容相关的评论的数量在统计学上与解释质量显着相关。迄今为止,这些发现仅在有关经典力学主题的解释性视频的背景下观察到。出现问题是,是否可以找到有关难以在视觉和口头上难以访问的主题的视频(例如从量子物理学)找到的视频之间的相似相关性。因此,我们进行了一项探索性研究,分析了n = 60 YouTube视频的解释质量有关量子纠缠和隧道。为此,我们利用了基于类别的解释性视频的解释质量的量度。我们报告了视频的解释质量与YouTube提供的表面特征之间的相关性。一方面,我们的结果证实了机械主题的早期发现。另一方面,部分相关性为YouTube表面特征与解释视频的质量之间的关系提供了新的启示。

Physics education research on explanatory videos has experienced a boost in recent years. Due to the vast number of explanatory videos available online, e.g. on YouTube, finding videos of high explaining quality is a challenging task for learners, teachers, and lecturers alike. Prior research on the explaining quality of explanatory videos on classical mechanics topics has uncovered that the surface features provided by YouTube (e.g. number of views or likes) do not seem to be suitable indicators of the videos' explaining quality. Instead, the number of content-related comments was found to be statistically significantly correlated with the explaining quality. To date, these findings have only been observed in the context of explanatory videos on classical mechanics topics. The question arises whether similar correlations between the explaining quality and YouTube surface features can be found for videos on topics that are difficult to access visually and verbally, for example from quantum physics. Therefore, we conducted an exploratory study analyzing the explaining quality of N = 60 YouTube videos on quantum entanglement and tunnelling. To this end, we made use of a category-based measure of explanatory videos' explaining quality from the literature. We report correlations between the videos' explaining quality, and the surface features provided by YouTube. On the one hand, our results substantiate earlier findings for mechanics topics. On other hand, partial correlations shed new light on the relationship between YouTube's surface features and explaining quality of explanatory videos.

扫码加入交流群

加入微信交流群

微信交流群二维码

扫码加入学术交流群,获取更多资源